Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Soléne's avatar

Whilst I really enjoy your content, especially your posts regarding faith and upbringing but I have to disagree with this underlying assumption that skepticism and faith are somehow inherently opposed to one another. Many of the greatest theological minds—Augustine, Aquinas, Pascal—were complete skeptics who interrogated their faith incredibly thoroughly, with Augustines entire journey in Confessions being about questioning everything before arriving at faith. Similarly with thinkers such as Anselm and Aquinas, who engaged deeply with philosophy and reason rather than just believing blindly in their religion. Faith, if properly understood, is not some sort of passive acceptance but an engagement with deeper questions of existence. In his letters to the Corinthians (1 Corinthians 13:5) Paul encourages inward/internal self-examination - on whether you truly believe and live by Christs teachings and while 1 Peter 3:15 focuses more on external defense, both suggest that faith should not be blind or unexamined. Peter implies that one should know their faith so thoroughly that when time calls for it one can articulate it clearly to others whilst Paul calls for deep self-reflection to ensure one’s faith is genuine. Together, they point toward a faith that is both intellectually and personally grounded. Your concern that many believers fail to question their faith is valid, but it does not necessarily indicative of faith itself as true faith is marked by the ability to doubt and come to one’s own conclusions or to dig in further. If anything, unexamined belief is a weakness but is not reflective of religion as a whole. Your own journey which you mentioned as marked by questioning and intellectual engagement is precisely the kind of thinking that leads to a faith more profound than mere cultural or habitual religiosity and has lead to much of the theological backbone that makes up religions such as Christianity today. I hope you to a conclusion about your faith you find agreeable and peaceful.

Expand full comment
Noelle Julianna's avatar

I came for the writing, but I’m here for the Tumblr vibes. Love the images you integrate into your posts!

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts