40 Comments
User's avatar
Manda's avatar

You *have* to read “Garden Spells” by Sarah Addison Allen. The cover is dreamy and it’s written so similarly to the Practical Magic movie- loved it wayyyyy more than the Practical Magic book (though Rules of Magic is amazing).

Expand full comment
caitlyn's avatar

Thank you for this! I’ll have to check it out 🤎

Expand full comment
Emily's avatar

Highly recommend "A League of Gentlewomen Witches" by India Holton

Expand full comment
caitlyn's avatar

I read about that one this morning on Goodreads! I’ll have to check it out 🤎🤎

Expand full comment
Natalie McGlocklin's avatar

I wrote a whole post last year called "comfort me with witchcraft" I love this SO MUCH.

Expand full comment
caitlyn's avatar

That title!!! 🤭🤎

Expand full comment
Laura-Louise Slattery's avatar

Reading this post is making me so excited for autumn. I still need to read Practical Magic. So many people I know loved it and I've never watched the movie either. I'd like to read the book first though.

Expand full comment
— nikki's message to you —'s avatar

i love this so much especially witch content is the main content i grew up with...

i had this thought in my brain that being a witch was something that was meant to be.

nowadays, i have an interest in the aspect of witchcraft but, still contemplating whether i want to get involved.

love this so much!

Expand full comment
caitlyn's avatar

☺️🤎✨ yesss all the witchy vibes!

Expand full comment
Gabriella's avatar

I JUST finished The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches and rewatched Practical Magic, so its good to know I'm not the only one yearning for magic and witchiness. I'm leaving for New England in a couple weeks, visiting Salem of course, so I wanted to get in the mood

Expand full comment
caitlyn's avatar

I can’t even begin to describe how jealous I am! My dream is to live in New England 🥺🤎✨ I hope you have the BEST time and do all the cozy witchy things!

Expand full comment
Gabriella's avatar

My dad's family is from Portsmouth, NH and Newcastle Island, be sure to check out for the witchiness. I hope so much you live in a little colonial house with lots of hydrangeas and pumpkins one day!

Expand full comment
Bianca's avatar

Highly recommend The Spellshop by Sarah Beth Durst🤩

Expand full comment
caitlyn's avatar

Oooo that sounds like a good one!✨🤎

Expand full comment
Mary Beth's avatar

Yay!!! Glad I’m not the only one that loves those aesthetic witchy YouTube channels while reading :) :) :) thanks for the additions to my autumn reading list!

Expand full comment
caitlyn's avatar

It sets to mood and aids in the escapism 🙂‍↔️✨

Expand full comment
Strawberi's avatar

If you like witch themed fiction, I loved A Hat Full of Sky by Terry Pratchet and The Witch’s Kind & The Age of Witches both by Lousia Morgan. They were all wonderful reads! Terry Pratchets book has more of a Kiki’s delivery service vibe while Louisa Morgan’s novels are more like historian fiction/ practical magic vibes (but they still have some cool magic stuff going on)

Expand full comment
caitlyn's avatar

Thank you for much for all these recs! Can’t wait to check them out 🥰

Expand full comment
Laney Lenox's avatar

I cannot wait to add these to my library list come the spooky months!! I keep telling my husband that I'm so excited for autumn, and he keeps telling me to still enjoy summer first- can't help it, just love that season!

Expand full comment
Emily K's avatar

So excited to delve into this list!!!

Expand full comment
Joseph Louis's avatar

Currently working on a witchy book, maybe one day it’ll be on your future list.

Expand full comment
Nastia's avatar

This post makes me SO happy 🐈‍⬛🧹🌿🧙‍♀️ Thank you for so many amazing recs!

Expand full comment
aurora blythe 💌's avatar

i loved this list! already added all the books to my amazon wishlist, thank you for sharing!

Expand full comment
caitlyn's avatar

You’re so welcome 🤎✨

Expand full comment
Alyssa aka Nerdy Nurse Reads's avatar

I loved The House Witch!! Thank you for this wonderful list of cozy witchy books

Expand full comment
caitlyn's avatar

I’m glad you enjoyed 🤎🤎

Expand full comment
Ashley Maria 🥀's avatar

"if you’re into cozy and witchy, you’re my people. just you wait until the ‘ber months. i will be popping my p*ssy so hard in these upcoming letters with recs." -- When I read this I hollered. 🤣 I can't wait. Buss it open girl. ✨🧹

Expand full comment
caitlyn's avatar

🤎🤎🤎 I can’t wait to share more!

Expand full comment